• About
  • Advertise
  • Contact
Sunday, May 18, 2025
No Result
View All Result
NEWSLETTER
Orthodox Times (en)
  • Home
  • Orthodoxy
    • Ecumenical Patriarchate
      • Dioceses of the Ecumenical Patriarchate
      • Mount Athos
      • Archdiocese of America
      • Archdiocese of Australia
      • Church of Crete
    • Patriarchates
      • Patriarchate of Alexandria
      • Patriarchate of Antioch
      • Patriarchate of Moscow
      • Patriarchate of Serbia
      • Patriarchate of Romania
      • Patriarchate of Jerusalem
      • Patriarchate of Bulgaria
      • Patriarchate of Georgia
    • Churches
      • Church of Greece
      • Church of Cyprus
      • Church of Poland
      • Church of Albania
      • Church of Czech and Slovakia
      • Church of Ukraine
  • Politics
    • USA
    • Europe
    • Middle East
  • Society
    • Greek Diaspora
    • Culture
  • Spirituality
  • Christianity
  • Opinions
  • Home
  • Orthodoxy
    • Ecumenical Patriarchate
      • Dioceses of the Ecumenical Patriarchate
      • Mount Athos
      • Archdiocese of America
      • Archdiocese of Australia
      • Church of Crete
    • Patriarchates
      • Patriarchate of Alexandria
      • Patriarchate of Antioch
      • Patriarchate of Moscow
      • Patriarchate of Serbia
      • Patriarchate of Romania
      • Patriarchate of Jerusalem
      • Patriarchate of Bulgaria
      • Patriarchate of Georgia
    • Churches
      • Church of Greece
      • Church of Cyprus
      • Church of Poland
      • Church of Albania
      • Church of Czech and Slovakia
      • Church of Ukraine
  • Politics
    • USA
    • Europe
    • Middle East
  • Society
    • Greek Diaspora
    • Culture
  • Spirituality
  • Christianity
  • Opinions
No Result
View All Result
Orthodox Times (en)
No Result
View All Result

New “attack” by the Church of Albania to the Phanar for the Ukrainian issue

Nov 15, 2022 | 17:04
in Church of Albania, FrontPage
New “attack” by the Church of Albania to the Phanar for the Ukrainian issue

By Efi Efthimiou

In today’s announcement, the Church of Albania expressed its opposition once again to the process of granting the Autocephaly to the Orthodox Church of Ukraine by the Ecumenical Patriarchate.

On the occasion of a postgraduate thesis by Archimandrite Fr. Gregory Farmakis (Chief Secretary of the Ecumenical Patriarchate) “On the Treatment of the Church Issue in Ukraine by the Mother Church of Constantinople (The issue of ordinations)”, the Church of Albania stressed that the granting of the Ukrainian Autocephaly brought neither peace nor unity, but the consequences of this decision were “unfavorable to all Orthodoxy”.

It pointed out that what is mentioned in the paper on the granting of the Autocephaly to the Church of Albania in 1937 “is inaccurate and indirectly misleading”.

The Church of Albania stressed that all cases of schism, as well as various diseases, were not treated with the same treatment, and each needed a different one. “The same applies to schisms”.

However, it stressed that “the Church of Albania did not adopt a Russian view, on the contrary, it was the first to point out and condemn the use of the sacrament of the Divine Eucharist for the imposition of the positions of the Patriarchate of Moscow.”

It stated that it has not in any way called into question the right to ekkleton or the need to grant Ukraine an autocephaly.

However, it proposed that the same procedure should apply that led to the solution of the Melitian Schism by the First Ecumenical Synod, while stating “as it should, with true love, the reasonable dogmatic reservation as to the process of providing the Autocephaly”.

Finally, it reiterated the need to convene a Pan-Orthodox Synaxis in order to “regulate an ecclesiastical issue that afflicts the Orthodox around the world”.

Read below the announcement:

Regarding the Master’s Paper

Of the Archimandrite Fr. Grigorios Frangakis

On “The Ecclesiastical Issue in the Ukraine”

The Master’s paper of the Archimandrite Fr. Gregorios Frangakis – Chief Secretary of the Great Church of Christ, with the topic “About the Healing of the Ecclesiastical Issue in Ukraine by the Mother Church of Constantinople. (The Issue of Ordinations)”, which was submitted recently to the Theological Faculty of Thessaloniki (AUTH) and was posted on the internet, also discusses the granting of Autocephaly to the Church of Albania in 1937. However, what is mentioned is inexact and indirectly misleading. The differences are obvious:

Bishop Visarion Xhuvani, who was ordained in 1925 and was self-proclaimed in 1929 as “Archbishop” of an Autocephalous Church, did not apply for an ekkleton, as Filaret is considered to have done. He asked for forgiveness, which was granted to him. Simultaneously, however, no acting position was bestowed on him in the Orthodox Church of Albania when she was proclaimed Autocephalous in 1937.

Bishop Agathangelos was ordained by Visarion on February 12th, 1929. He was defrocked together with all of the members of the Synod, as announced by the Encyclical of the Ecumenical Patriarchate “To the Pious Orthodox Pleroma in Albania” on February 25th, 1929. Therefore, Agathangelos did not receive ordination from a defrocked, excommunicated, and anathematized Bishop, as was the case with Epiphanius, nor did he become a Primate of an Autocephalous Church. In Albania, no group was ignored, as in the case of Metropolitan Onufriy together with at least 90 Bishops.

It is also worth noting that in the relevant Patriarchal and Synodal Tomos of Autocephaly, the Church of Albania is called “sister” three times and nowhere is referenced to as “daughter”, similarly all the local Orthodox Churches are called “sisters” three times and nowhere “daughters”, as is written in the Tomos of Ukraine. Most importantly however, peace and unity have been brought to Albania, in contrast to what has happened in Ukraine, with unpropitious consequences for all Orthodoxy.

Finally, in the Tomos of Ukraine the following is written: “In addition to the above, we declare that the Autocephalous Church in Ukraine knows as its head the most holy Apostolic and Patriarchal Ecumenical Throne, just as the rest of the Patriarchs and Primates also do”. A similar reference does not exist in the Tomos of Autocephaly of the Orthodox Church of Albania.

****
All the cases mentioned in the Master’s paper referenced to above as analogues (Bulgaria, Serbia, etc.) are a juxtaposition of dissimilar facts in relation to the ecclesiastical issue of the Ukraine. Through the course of the centuries, several schisms occurred in many local Churches due to various factors and conditions. According to the writer of the paper, the various cases are altogether considered as a single disease, which is called “schism”, requiring the same therapy. However, just as various diseases – tuberculosis, malaria, cancer, etc. – are each defeated by a different therapeutic treatment, likewise the same holds true to schism.

The case of Ukraine is similar to the Melitian Schism, as analyzed in the study of Metropolitan Vasilios of Smyrna, formerly of Anchialos, which was sent to us by the Ecumenical Patriarchate with its letter of response of February 20th, 2019. The correction of the Schism of the Melitians and the ‘by oikonomia’ integration into the Church of those invalidly ordained by Melitius comprised the following phases: a) repentance, b) laying on of hands by a canonical Bishop and prayer, according to the phrase of Saint Athanasios “it was decided… that those who were appointed by him to be restored to communion after being confirmed through a μυστικωτέρᾳ χειροτονίᾳ βεβαιωθέντας mistikotera hierotonia veveothendas (mystical, inaudible ordination)”[1] (with the simple laying on of hands each one was approved in their sacerdotal ranks), and c) the attainment of peace through the decision of a Pan-Orthodox Synod. This is a principle that is valid for the reincorporation of all similar schismatic cases into the Orthodox Church and determines an interesting exodos from the existing problem.

In general, it is accepted that the ordaining Bishop acts in the name of the Church, when he is within Her as “a steward of the sacraments of God”. Outside of Her, he is deprived of every sacerdotal grace and each holy act is invalid and inexistant.

The theory of the indelible priesthood, which has been adopted by the Roman Catholic world, (even if it is temporarily accepted as a working hypothesis), does not constitute an argument for the transmission of the grace and the validity of apostolic succession. Even if it is supposed that there remained imprints from the ordination, when the ordainer is cut off from the Church, defrocked, anathematized, and excommunicated, he becomes inactive and does not transmit any grace, (like an electrical device does not transmit any energy when it is cut off from the electrical current). Nor definitely does this that never occurred becomes as having occurred, existing, valid, through a simple administrative decision. This is exactly where the concern for the validity of the ordination of Epiphanius by Filaret is based.
Certainly, the Church as the fount of divine grace acts according to akrivia in certain instances and in other cases according to oikonomia, always with the purpose of concordance “to keep the unity of the Spirit in the bond of peace” (Eph. 4:3), in significant cases in a Pan-Orthodox Synod, in order that doubts do not exist.

The Church of Albania did not adopt a Russian point of view, on the contrary, she was the first who pointed out and condemned the use of the Holy Mystery of the Divine Eucharist for the imposition of the opinions of the Patriarchate of Moscow. She by no means doubted the right of ekkleton nor the need for the granting of Autocephaly in Ukraine. In the letter of response to the Ecumenical Patriarchate of March 19th, 2019 she proposed for the same procedure that led to the solution of the Melitian Schism by the First Ecumenical Synod to be applied. She expressed, as she ought, speaking the truth in love, reasonable dogmatic reservations referring to the process of the granting of Autocephaly, proposed, as did other Orthodox Churches, and continues to request that a Pan-Orthodox Synaxis be convoked, which in the Holy Spirit will normalize an ecclesiastical issue that afflicts the Orthodox people around the world.

The fundamental conviction remains that the Divine Eucharist, Apostolic Succession, and Synodality are the unshakeable foundation of Orthodox unity and that which is desired remains peace and the unity of Orthodoxy throughout the world.

Tirana November 15th, 2022

(From the Chief Secretariat of the Holy Synod of the Orthodox Autocephalous Church of Albania)

Tags: Church of Albania

Follow OrthodoxTimes.com on Google News and learn all the news about Orthodoxy in Greece and worldwide.

All the latest developments in the Orthodox world, society and humankind, at the moment they happen, at OrthodoxTimes.com


Related Posts

Albanian Orthodox Church Commemorates Saint John the Theologian
Church of Albania

Albanian Orthodox Church Commemorates Saint John the Theologian

May 8, 2025
Archbishop of Albania pays first pastoral visit to St. Vlash Monastery for Feast of Myrrh-Bearing Women
Church of Albania

Archbishop of Albania pays first pastoral visit to St. Vlash Monastery for Feast of Myrrh-Bearing Women

May 5, 2025
Thomas Sunday celebrated across the Church of Albania
Church of Albania

Thomas Sunday celebrated across the Church of Albania

April 28, 2025
Archbishop of Albania at the funeral mass for Pope Francis
Church of Albania

Archbishop of Albania at the funeral mass for Pope Francis

April 26, 2025
Festive Hierarchical Concelebration in Tirana for the feast of Saint George the Great Martyr
Church of Albania

Festive Hierarchical Concelebration in Tirana for the feast of Saint George the Great Martyr

April 23, 2025
Condolences from the Orthodox Church of Albania on the passing of Pope Francis
Church of Albania

Condolences from the Orthodox Church of Albania on the passing of Pope Francis

April 21, 2025
Load More
Next Post
Memory of Holy Apostle and Evangelist Matthew

Memory of Holy Apostle and Evangelist Matthew

Latest News

Archbishop of America bestowed crosses on Holy Cross Class of 2025

Archbishop of America bestowed crosses on Holy Cross Class of 2025

by NewsRoom
May 18, 2025 | 12:41
0

On May 16, 2025, the Hellenic College Holy Cross community gathered in joy and reverence for the services of...

Darwin welcomed Archbishop of Australia for new Church dedication

Darwin welcomed Archbishop of Australia for new Church dedication

by NewsRoom
May 18, 2025 | 11:30
0

On Saturday, May 17, Archbishop Makarios of Australia arrived in the city of Darwin to preside over the foundation...

Pope Leo XIV: I was chosen having no merit of my own, I am here as a brother and servant (VIDEO)

Pope Leo XIV: I was chosen having no merit of my own, I am here as a brother and servant (VIDEO)

by NewsRoom
May 18, 2025 | 11:02
0

Last update: 13:26 Shortly after 11:00 a.m. Greek time, the official enthronement ceremony of Pope Leo XIV, who was...

Sunday of the Samaritan Woman: Faith and Repentance at Jacob’s Well

Sunday of the Samaritan Woman: Faith and Repentance at Jacob’s Well

by NewsRoom
May 18, 2025 | 10:09
0

Introduction The fifth Sunday of Holy Pascha is observed by the Orthodox Church as the Sunday of the Samaritan...

Strategic planning and renewal marked HCHC Board meeting before commencement

Strategic planning and renewal marked HCHC Board meeting before commencement

by NewsRoom
May 17, 2025 | 17:48
0

On the eve of the 83rd Commencement at Hellenic College Holy Cross Greek Orthodox School of Theology, its Board...

HCHC to award honorary degrees to Fr. Alexander Karloutsos and Helen A. Carlos

HCHC to award honorary degrees to Fr. Alexander Karloutsos and Helen A. Carlos

by NewsRoom
May 17, 2025 | 17:38
0

Hellenic College Holy Cross Greek Orthodox School of Theology is awarding honorary degrees to two esteemed leaders whose contributions...

Newsletter

Sign up for our weekly newsletter



Quick Links

  • Orthodoxy
  • Politics
  • Society
  • Spirituality
  • Christianity
  • Opinions
  • History
  • Press Releases

Get Social

About Us

Advertise

Contact

Terms Of Use

© 2025 OrthodoxTimes.com
digital world media

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Orthodoxy
    • Ecumenical Patriarchate
      • Dioceses of the Ecumenical Patriarchate
      • Mount Athos
      • Archdiocese of America
      • Archdiocese of Australia
      • Church of Crete
    • Patriarchates
      • Patriarchate of Alexandria
      • Patriarchate of Antioch
      • Patriarchate of Moscow
      • Patriarchate of Serbia
      • Patriarchate of Romania
      • Patriarchate of Jerusalem
      • Patriarchate of Bulgaria
      • Patriarchate of Georgia
    • Churches
      • Church of Greece
      • Church of Cyprus
      • Church of Poland
      • Church of Albania
      • Church of Czech and Slovakia
      • Church of Ukraine
  • Politics
    • USA
    • Europe
    • Middle East
  • Society
    • Greek Diaspora
    • Culture
  • Spirituality
  • Christianity
  • Opinions
  • Greek Version

© 2023 OrthodoxTimes.com - All rights reserved.

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish.AcceptReject Read More
Privacy & Cookies Policy

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience.
Necessary
Always Enabled

Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.

Non-necessary

Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.

SAVE & ACCEPT