Elder Metropolitan Emmanuel of Chalcedon, reflected on the significance of the Holy and Great Council of the Orthodox Church, the decade since its convocation in Crete and the continuing need for the reception of its decisions in the life of the Church.
Speaking on behalf of the Organizing Committee, Metropolitan Emmanuel welcomed Ecumenical Patriarch Bartholomew at the opening of the conference “The Holy and Great Council of the Orthodox Church (2016–2026): Assessment and Prospects,” held in Chantilly, France, on Monday, October 5.
“Ten years,” he began, recalling that a decade has passed since Pentecost Sunday in June 2016, when the Primates and delegations of ten Autocephalous Orthodox Churches began the work of the Holy and Great Council with the celebration of the Divine Liturgy.
For the history of the Church, he observed, a decade is a very short period, yet it is sufficient “to see what has taken root and what still awaits.”
From Rhodes to Crete
Metropolitan Emmanuel recalled the lengthy process that led to the Council, beginning with the First Pan-Orthodox Conference in Rhodes in 1961, convened by Ecumenical Patriarch Athenagoras, and continuing through the First Preconciliar Pan-Orthodox Conference in Chambésy in 1976 and decades of preparatory work.
Texts were drafted and reconsidered over many years, he noted, while many of those who contributed to the preparations did not live to see the Council finally convened.
He paid particular tribute to the late Metropolitan John Zizioulas of Pergamon for his contribution to both the preparation and the work of the Council.
Addressing Ecumenical Patriarch Bartholomew, Metropolitan Emmanuel stressed that the final—and perhaps most difficult—stage of the preconciliar process was closely associated with his leadership.
He recalled the Synaxis of the Primates at the Phanar in March 2014, when it was decided that the Council would convene in 2016, and the January 2016 Synaxis in Chambésy, when Crete was selected as its venue.
Behind those dates, he said, were “contacts with the sister Churches, letters, visits, persistence and patience—above all, patience.”
“The Absence of Four Churches Still Hurts”
Metropolitan Emmanuel also addressed the absence from Crete of the Churches of Antioch, Russia, Bulgaria and Georgia.
“That caused pain. It still hurts,” he said.
Nevertheless, he stressed that the Council convened, completed its work and addressed its decisions to the entire Orthodox pleroma, including those Churches that did not participate.
What Took Root — and What Remained on Paper?
Turning to the purpose of the Chantilly conference, Metropolitan Emmanuel explained that the organizers did not want simply to commemorate an anniversary, but to reassess the Council’s documents in light of the experience of the past decade.
The central question, he said, is “what among them entered the life of the Churches and what, for the time being, remained on paper.”
He emphasized that the reception of a Council cannot simply be imposed by decisions, but gradually takes place within the fullness of the Church.
The conference is therefore examining the Council’s Encyclical and Message, the Orthodox Diaspora, autonomy and the manner of its proclamation, relations between the Orthodox Church and the rest of the Christian world, marriage and its impediments, fasting, and the mission of the Church in the contemporary world.
A separate session is also devoted to the document For the Life of the World, concerning the social ethos of the Orthodox Church, while a roundtable on Thursday will offer an initial overall assessment.
“An initial one,” Metropolitan Emmanuel stressed, “because it will not be the last.”
“The Spirit Goes Before Us; We Follow”
Concluding his address, Metropolitan Emmanuel referred to the Apostolic Council of Jerusalem and the words from the Acts of the Apostles: “For it seemed good to the Holy Spirit and to us.”
“The Spirit goes before us; we follow,” he said, adding that this was the order Ecumenical Patriarch Bartholomew sought to serve as President of the Holy and Great Council.
Referring finally to the Kontakion of Pentecost and its proclamation that the Most High “called all to unity,” Metropolitan Emmanuel said:
“That call has not grown old and, ten years after Crete, it is also addressed to us who have gathered here.”
With these words, he invited Ecumenical Patriarch Bartholomew to formally declare the anniversary conference open.














